Skip links

Process Hazard Analysis (PHA/HAZOP) for CalARP & RMP

Home › Environmental › CalARP › Process Hazard Analysis (PHA/HAZOP)

Process Hazard Analysis (PHA/HAZOP) for CalARP & RMP

The Process Hazard Analysis is the engine inside every Program 3 CalARP plan.

The Process Hazard Analysis is the engine inside every Program 3 CalARP plan. It is the structured study that identifies what can go wrong in a covered process, how bad the consequences could be, and what safeguards keep the worst outcomes from happening. Program 2 plans require a hazard review instead, a less formal assessment that covers the same ground at a level that fits simpler processes. The federal RMP rule and California’s CalARP regulation both require the appropriate study at each program level. Cal/OSHA’s Process Safety Management standard requires a full PHA for the same processes. When a CUPA (your local administering agency) reviewer flags a plan as thin, the hazard analysis section is usually where the thinness shows.

For the broader picture of when a facility needs a CalARP plan and what else goes inside it, see our CalARP and Risk Management Plan compliance guide for California. This piece covers what a process hazard analysis is and where the requirement comes from, how the PHA is built for a CalARP or federal RMP submittal, what HAZOP looks like in practice, and what California reviewers expect to see.

Team reviewing process documents inside a manufacturing facility

What CalARP and RMP Require From a PHA

The PHA requirement appears in three overlapping rules. Federal RMP at 40 CFR §68.67 requires a PHA for every Program 3 covered process. Program 2 processes require a hazard review under 40 CFR §68.48, which covers the same territory but with a less formal structure. California’s CalARP regulation adopts the federal framework at both program levels. Cal/OSHA’s Process Safety Management standard at Title 8 §5189 requires a PHA for every covered process at a California workplace. For a side-by-side of the three programs, see our breakdown of CalARP vs. federal RMP vs. Cal/OSHA PSM.

The substance of the requirement is the same across all three. Every PHA must identify:

  • The hazards of the process
  • Previous incidents at the facility or in the industry with the potential for catastrophic consequences
  • Engineering and administrative controls that apply, and the consequences if those controls fail
  • Facility siting (where vessels, control rooms, and occupied buildings sit in relation to each other)
  • Human factors (how people interact with the process and where errors could trigger a release)
  • A qualitative evaluation of a range of possible safety and health effects on workers

For California facilities, external events are the place where the PHA most often pulls in other studies. Seismic exposure has to be addressed for CalARP processes; for how that piece is handled separately, see our overview of CalARP seismic assessment in California. The PHA also feeds the offsite consequence analysis, because the failure scenarios identified during the PHA are usually what drive the alternative release scenarios in the OCA.

Choosing a Methodology

The regulation does not pick a methodology for you. For Program 3 processes, the federal RMP rule at 40 CFR §68.67(c) lists six accepted PHA approaches: What-If, Checklist, What-If/Checklist, HAZOP (Hazard and Operability Study), FMEA (Failure Mode and Effects Analysis), Fault Tree Analysis, or any other equivalent methodology. California CalARP follows the same list. Program 2 hazard reviews are less prescriptive about methodology but must still identify hazards, safeguards, and recommendations. The right choice depends on the process and the program level.

Swipe to see all columns →
Accepted PHA methodologies, what each fits, and relative effort
MethodologyBest forEffort
ChecklistWell-understood processes with mature operating historyLow
What-IfSmaller, simpler covered processes (often Program 2)Low-medium
What-If / ChecklistThe default combination for many Program 2 facilitiesMedium
HAZOPComplex Program 3 processes with multiple unit operations and interlocksHigh
FMEAEquipment-driven hazards (instrumentation, mechanical failure modes)High
Fault TreeQuantifying the probability of a specific top eventHigh

HAZOP is the methodology most often used on Program 3 plans because it forces a node-by-node walkthrough of the process and surfaces deviations a checklist would miss. The trade-off is time. A HAZOP for a multi-stage ammonia refrigeration system or a chlorine handling line can run several full study days with operators, engineers, and the facilitator at the table.

How a HAZOP Worksheet Is Built

The deliverable inside a HAZOP-based PHA is a structured worksheet that documents every deviation the team considered. The columns track the analysis the same way on every Program 3 plan we deliver:

Swipe to see all columns →
Example HAZOP worksheet structure with worked rows
NodeParameterGuidewordDeviationCauseConsequenceSafeguardsRecommendation
Ammonia receiver vesselPressureMoreHigh pressure in receiverLoss of cooling, blocked outletRelief valve discharge, possible releasePSV-101, high-pressure alarm, operator responseVerify PSV inspection date; confirm alarm setpoint
Liquid transfer lineFlowLess / NoNo flow during transferClosed valve, pump tripPressure buildup upstream, hose ruptureBypass procedure, low-flow alarmAdd written procedure for blocked transfer
Compressor dischargeTemperatureMoreHigh discharge temperatureLoss of intercooler, fouled exchangerLubricant breakdown, mechanical failureHigh-temp shutdown, daily checkConfirm shutdown setpoint matches manufacturer specification

The same structure repeats across every node in the process. A node is a defined section of the process (a vessel, a piping segment, a heat exchanger). A guideword (more, less, none, reverse, as well as, part of, other than) is paired with a parameter (flow, pressure, temperature, level, composition) to produce a deviation. The team then walks through cause, consequence, existing safeguards, and recommended actions for each deviation it considers credible. Done well, the worksheet runs hundreds of lines for a complex Program 3 process.

Need a PHA, HAZOP, or hazard review completed for your CalARP plan?We will scope the process, recommend a methodology that fits the complexity and program level, and facilitate the study with your operations team.

How CDMS Runs a PHA

We have facilitated PHAs and HAZOPs for California CalARP and RMP plans for more than 30 years, across ammonia refrigeration, chlorine handling, anhydrous and aqueous acid systems, cyanide processes, and flammable liquid operations. When we run a study on a covered process, the work falls into five steps:

1

Pre-study site walk and document gathering.

We walk the process with your operators, collect current P&IDs (piping and instrumentation diagrams), operating procedures, relief valve sizing calculations, alarm and interlock lists, and the five-year incident history. The PHA is only as good as the information that enters the room.

2

Node definition and study planning.

We break the process into nodes, decide which guideword/parameter pairs the team will walk through at each node, and schedule the study sessions around operations.

3

Facilitated study sessions.

Our facilitator runs the meeting; the operators, maintenance lead, process engineer, and a member of the EHS team carry the operational knowledge. The most common issue we see in plans we audit is a PHA that was filled out by a consultant without the operators in the room. CUPA reviewers can usually tell.

4

Documentation and recommendation tracking.

Every deviation gets a worksheet entry. Every recommendation gets an owner and a target date. The recommendation log becomes part of the prevention program and feeds management-of-change reviews.

5

Integration with the rest of the plan.

Findings flow into the PHA section of the CalARP or RMP submittal, the OCA scenarios, the operating procedures, the training plan, and the mechanical integrity program. A PHA that sits in its own binder and never touches the rest of the plan is a finding waiting to happen.

For ammonia refrigeration specifically, the PHA usually pulls in IIAR (International Institute of Ammonia Refrigeration) standards as the RAGAGEP (Recognized And Generally Accepted Good Engineering Practice) baseline. For the full ammonia angle, see our guide to ammonia refrigeration and CalARP compliance in California.

The Five-Year Revalidation Rule

A PHA is not a one-time document. Federal RMP at 40 CFR §68.67(f) and Cal/OSHA PSM at Title 8 §5189 both require the PHA to be updated and revalidated at least every five years. California CalARP follows the same cycle and the five-year revalidation is what most facilities encounter when their CalARP plan comes up for renewal. For how the renewal cycle works, see our piece on CalARP 5-year updates.

Revalidation is not a rewrite. It is a structured review that confirms the original PHA is still accurate for the process as it operates today, captures any management-of-change items added in the interim, and addresses any incidents or near-misses from the prior five years. If the process has changed materially, revalidation often turns into a new study for the affected nodes.

The other trigger is a process change. Any management of change that affects how the process operates, what chemicals it handles, or the safeguards in place should kick off a focused PHA on the changed portion before the change goes live. Pre-startup safety review and management of change procedures both depend on the PHA being current.

Ready to schedule a PHA or HAZOP for your CalARP, RMP, or PSM-covered process?We will facilitate the study with your operators on site, document the worksheet to the standard CUPA reviewers expect, and integrate the findings into the rest of your plan.

Trusted throughout California

  • US Foods client logo
  • Azenta client logo
  • Brooks client logo
  • Element Critical client logo
  • Admedes client logo
  • FS Precision Tech client logo
  • Western Colloid client logo
  • Endevco client logo
  • StoreDot client logo
  • Advantage Metal Products client logo
  • Levlad client logo
  • E-Fab client logo
BSY started working with CDMS last year after our in-house EHS person departed the company. CDMS reviewed our existing operational permits as well as any additional Federal, State and Local regulations that could apply and helped us to create a comprehensive compliance calendar to track regulatory deadlines and submittal due dates. The CDMS team does an excellent job of tracking everything and can be relied upon to complete the forms accurately and assist with submittals, allowing me to focus on our business.
Gerona Goethe · General Manager · Bay Ship

Speak with a CDMS EHS expert

Tell us about your facility and your deadline. You’ll get a clear read on what applies and a scoped plan to handle it.